Go to main contentsGo to search barGo to main menu
Friday, November 20, 2026 at 3:01 PM

Council debates utility ordinance, rate transparency

Whitesboro
Council debates utility ordinance, rate transparency

The Whitesboro City Council spent much of its Nov. 10 meeting discussing how council members and city staff can work together to bring items before the council, with particular attention to utility billing policies and transparency regarding city rates.

The discussion began with consideration of amendments to Ordinance 1276, specifically Sections 51.005 and 51.006, which address how the city handles utility accounts when it suspects an account is being transferred from one person’s name to another to avoid paying an overdue balance.

City Administrator Phil Harris explained that under the existing ordinance, an unpaid utility balance could follow an individual who moved to another residence within the city. Following discussions with the city’s attorneys, proposed amendments were drafted to reflect changes in state law while addressing situations in which residents repeatedly switch account holders to avoid paying outstanding balances.

Harris said the changes would “prevent the merry-go-round exercise” of residents switching accounts to avoid paying for utility services.

“This helps us accommodate for that because we’ve seen that behavior in the past,” Harris said.

Harris said the changes would protect both residents and the city.

City Attorney David Ritter explained that the amended ordinance would hold the person who incurred the utility charges responsible for the unpaid balance rather than assigning that responsibility to someone simply because they shared a residence.

State law also allows the city to examine the payment history of a particular rental property and require a higher deposit if there are concerns about account switching to avoid paying past-due balances. That provision was included in the proposed amendment.

Alderman Ben Edwards then raised concerns about both the proposed utility ordinance and a separate proposal he had submitted regarding transparency in the city’s rate changes.

Edwards said he had submitted two items to Harris for council consideration and requested that they be forwarded to the city attorney for review and recommendations before the deadline for placing items on the council agenda.

Despite submitting the proposals in time for review, Edwards said he was asked to table the items to allow additional time for consideration. He agreed, expecting to receive feedback before the Nov. 10 meeting.

However, Edwards said three weeks passed without an update. When he received the meeting materials, the proposed utility ordinance differed substantially from what he had submitted, while his proposal concerning rate transparency had been placed on the agenda as a discussion-only item.

“This clearly was not handled well,” Edwards said.

Edwards explained that his proposed utility amendment stemmed from a recent incident involving a resident who had an overdue balance at one address and subsequently moved into a home with another family member.

Although the family member at the second residence had no outstanding utility balance, Edwards said that person was informed the utilities would be disconnected unless the previous balance was paid.

Edwards emphasized that city staff had acted within the existing ordinance and had done nothing wrong.

“The problem I am trying to fix [is] the ordinance itself,” he said.

Edwards acknowledged that the city attorney’s proposed amendment addressed the original problem but expressed frustration with how the proposal had been handled.

“It contains none of the actual language I submitted. It is our job to change ordinances when they are not operating in the best interest of the city,” Edwards said.

He argued that the ordinance should explicitly state that one person cannot be held responsible for another person’s delinquent utility bill simply because they live together.

“I put explicit protections for citizens into my proposal and that explicit protection is not listed in any way in the ordinance before us,” Edwards said.

Although he agreed the proposed amendment resolved the issue, Edwards said it lacked the clarity he wanted for residents and city employees.

Edwards compared his original one-paragraph proposal with the city attorney’s two-page version. He said the attorney’s proposal included provisions allowing the city to require higher deposits when someone in a household had unpaid utility bills.

While that provision protected the city, Edwards argued, it did not provide the explicit protections for residents he had requested.

“That is not what I submitted for council consideration, and it should not have been changed,” Edwards said.

He said the lack of communication was not an isolated incident and pointed to the handling of his separate proposal concerning transparency in city rate changes.

Edwards said he submitted that proposal Oct. 6 and asked Harris to forward it to the city attorney for review so it could be presented for council discussion and a possible vote.

Instead, Edwards said he received an email indicating that Harris, Ritter and the city’s electric rate consultant had discussed the proposal.

His original recommendation called for providing utility customers 30 to 90 days’ advance notice of anticipated rate changes whenever reasonably possible.

“The consultant didn’t believe that the lengthy pre-notification period was possible,” Edwards said.

As a result, he said, the proposal was changed from an action item to a discussion-only item, accompanied by a four-page explanation rather than a proposed ordinance.

Edwards maintained that council members are responsible for introducing ordinances and proposing amendments, while the city administrator and city attorney are responsible for providing professional and legal advice.

“That is clearly our job,” Edwards said.

He requested that his proposed changes to the utility ordinance be considered and that the transparency proposal return to the council in a form that could be voted upon, preferably within a week.

Ritter responded that he needed clarification about how council members wanted the process for developing ordinances to work.

“It is unusual to receive a draft ordinance or resolution in complete form from a council member,” Ritter said.

He explained that the city attorney typically receives a general concern from a council member and develops an ordinance or resolution intended to address it.

In this case, Ritter said, Edwards had raised concerns about residents being held responsible for utility bills incurred by unrelated individuals. Ritter determined that the existing practice raised concerns under state law and drafted an amendment to address the issue.

At the same time, Harris had raised concerns about customers switching utility accounts to avoid unpaid balances. Ritter said he attempted to address both issues in the same ordinance.

Ritter noted that accepting fully drafted ordinances from individual council members could become complicated if several members submitted competing proposals on the same subject. Addressing each proposal separately could also increase the city’s legal expenses.

He reiterated that his usual approach was to take a council member’s concern and develop a proposal for the full council to consider.

Alderman David Bertino moved to approve the recommended amendment to Ordinance 1276.

Before the vote, Edwards reiterated that while he appreciated the work that went into the amendment, it addressed an additional issue that had not been part of his original request.

Edwards said he had asked Harris to have the city attorney contact him directly with questions about his proposals.

He acknowledged that council members do not typically submit fully drafted ordinances but maintained that doing so was within their responsibilities.

“It is not my intention to create an ordinance and then force it upon the council. It is my intention to create an ordinance that could be passed and then try to present it and convince the other councilmembers that it’s a good idea. That’s our job as legislators,” Edwards said.

The council approved the amendment as presented by Ritter in a 3-2 vote.

Bertino, Su Welch and Carla Woolsey voted in favor, while Ben Edwards and Jessica Edwards opposed the measure.

Council discusses rate transparency
Following the vote, Edwards returned to his proposal concerning public notification of city rate changes.

He argued that residents should receive information about changes affecting their utility bills as quickly as possible, including why rates are changing, when changes will take effect and, when possible, how much customers can expect their bills to increase.

Woolsey questioned whether some of the information Edwards wanted to provide was already included in notices the city is required to issue, such as those concerning property tax rates.

Ritter acknowledged that he should have contacted Edwards directly about the proposal.

He said he would have recommended presenting the proposal as a policy attached to a council resolution rather than as an ordinance. He also suggested that the proposed notification timeline might need to be adjusted.

Under the proposed policy, notices of city rate changes would include the current rate, the amount of the change, its effective date, an explanation of why the change was necessary, an estimate of the financial impact on customers and information about where residents could learn more.

Ritter noted that some of those requirements were already being met through existing city practices.

For example, property tax changes are subject to public notification requirements. Water and wastewater rates are generally reviewed with assistance from consultants to ensure the city collects enough revenue to cover the cost of providing those services.

Sanitation rates are typically reviewed when contracts come before the council, while information about changing utility rates is already presented during monthly meetings.

Ritter said the council could consider whether the additional reporting requirements would create a significant workload for city employees. However, he emphasized that the administrative burden was a policy consideration rather than a legal question.

When asked whether other cities had adopted similar transparency policies, Ritter said greater transparency was generally beneficial. He also noted that the state has a program recognizing municipalities that meet certain transparency standards.

Edwards responded that his primary concern was not whether the policy was legally required but whether the city was communicating clearly and promptly with residents.

He said many residents do not follow every council meeting but still want to know about decisions that could affect their household budgets.

Edwards argued that the city could use its website, social media accounts and news releases to communicate rate changes in addition to providing information during public meetings.

Woolsey asked whether Edwards primarily wanted the information posted on social media.

Edwards clarified that he wanted notices on the city’s official website and through other public communication channels.

Harris said the city already makes efforts to notify residents when possible but noted that utility bills have limited space for additional information about upcoming changes.

Edwards reiterated that the city should do everything reasonably possible to explain rate changes to the people responsible for paying the bills.

Woolsey said she believed the city was already being transparent, even if its current communication practices did not precisely match the procedures Edwards proposed.

Bertino said he did not believe another ordinance was necessary but welcomed the possibility of Ritter reviewing the proposal and bringing a recommendation back to the council.


Share
Rate